Side N
Jingye vs Britain — British Steel Compensation Claim
Which sources back which section of this article, and what its evidence base looks like.
Which sources back which section
| Section | Sources behind it |
|---|---|
| What Happened | UK Treaty Series No. 33 (1986) and its UN Treaty Series registration; British Steel (2020); Kluwer Arbitration Blog (2025); the Special Measures and Nationalisation Bills (2025, 2026); GOV.UK, 16 July 2026; HCWS273 (2026); the National Audit Office (2026); Al Jazeera, AP and the BBC (2026); Global Times, 19 July 2026; Jingye’s statements of 21 July and 25 August 2026; NPR (2026); GOV.UK ministerial appointments (2026); China’s Ministry of Commerce and Want Rich (2026); the ICSID and PCA case registers; Parliament’s record of statutory instruments |
| Timeline | UK Treaty Series No. 33 (1986); British Steel (2020); Kluwer Arbitration Blog (2025); Global Times, 11 June and 19 July 2026; GOV.UK, 16 July 2026; HCWS273 (2026); Al Jazeera and AP (2026); NPR (2026); GOV.UK ministerial appointments (2026); Jingye’s statements of 21 July and 25 August 2026; China’s Ministry of Commerce and Want Rich (2026); the ICSID and PCA case registers |
| The Argument | UK Treaty Series No. 33 (1986) and its UN Treaty Series registration; Kluwer Arbitration Blog (2025); EJIL:Talk! (2026) |
| What Others Add | The Nationalisation Bill (2026) and the Special Measures Bill (2025); Parliament’s record of statutory instruments; HCWS273 (2026) and HCWS723 (2025); GOV.UK, 16 July 2026; the National Audit Office (2026); Al Jazeera (2026); the BBC (2026); NPR (2026); GOV.UK ministerial appointments (2026); China’s Ministry of Commerce and Want Rich (2026) |
| Conclusion | UK Treaty Series No. 33 (1986); Kluwer Arbitration Blog (2025); EJIL:Talk! (2026); the Nationalisation Bill (2026); HCWS273 (2026); Parliament’s record of statutory instruments; the National Audit Office (2026); the BBC (2026); the ICSID and PCA case registers; Global Times editorial, 21 July 2026; Jingye’s statements of 21 July and 25 August 2026 |
What the evidence base looks like
- 26Sources behind this article
- 5Sections, every one of them sourced
- 26Read in full
- 11From the treaty, Parliament and the two governments’ own record
| What the source is | How many | How they were read |
|---|---|---|
| The treaty, the bills, statements to Parliament, the auditor’s report and the two governments’ own releases and records | 11 | All in full, at their own addresses or through Parliament’s public data services |
| News reporting and commentary | 8 | All in full; two through a republication of the same text |
| Legal analysis and arbitration case registers | 4 | All in full, at their own addresses |
| The former owner’s own formal statements | 2 | Both in full, at their own addresses |
| The company’s own 2020 announcement | 1 | In full, at its own address |
Reliable
Reliable, but with an interestWorth believing and reliableWeak on both, and used with careHonest, but thin
Worth believing