Tratopedia
Side N繁中
Settings

Text size

Language

Theme

High contrast

Version

v1.230.2

The release this page was built from. It is what the service worker caches under.

Investing Styles · Active Investing · Quantitative Funds · ExplainerDefinitions from 1991, sources read 5 Nov 2026

Investing styles, sorted · the active side

Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

Active investing is defined by what it is not: holding the whole market in the market’s own proportions. Everything else is active, and two further questions sort it — whether a person or a set of rules makes the call, and whether the reason to buy is a story or a set of numbers.

What is established, and what is a reading Each statement graded by what supports it

StandingWhatWhere it is set out
EstablishedA passive investor holds every security in the market, each in the same proportion as in the market; an active investor is one who is not passive.William F. Sharpe, 1991
EstablishedBefore costs the average actively managed dollar earns the market’s return; after costs it earns less than the average passively managed dollar.Sharpe, 1991
EstablishedSystematic trading follows rules; its opposite is discretionary trading, which can be swayed by emotion, is not easily back-tested and has less rigorous risk control.Wikipedia, “Systematic trading”
EstablishedA quantitative fund decides with systematic, data-driven methods rather than fundamental human analysis, often through factors such as value ratios, momentum or low volatility.Wikipedia, “Quantitative fund”
Established in researchBuying recent winners and selling recent losers earned about 1% a month over the following 3 to 12 months in Jegadeesh and Titman’s 1993 study.Wikipedia, “Momentum investing”
Established in researchNarratives, factual or not, justify actions as basic as spending and investing; they “go viral” and spread with economic impact.Robert J. Shiller, 2017
CharacterisationQuantitative techniques and systematic decisions are related but separate: a quantitative trade’s decision “may be systematic or discretionary”.Wikipedia, “Systematic trading”
Our readingActive investing can therefore be placed on two independent spectra — who decides, from a person to rules, and where the reason comes from, from a story to numbers — with most real strategies somewhere between the ends.This article, from the two Wikipedia entries above

How the vocabulary arrived Dated as the sources date them; the definitions themselves are older than any of these

  1. 1970sSystematic trading begins with the growth of computers (Wikipedia).
  2. Jan 1991Sharpe publishes “The Arithmetic of Active Management” in the Financial Analysts Journal.
  3. 1993Jegadeesh and Titman report the momentum result: about 1% a month for 3 to 12 months (Wikipedia).
  4. Jan 2017Shiller’s “Narrative Economics” appears as NBER Working Paper 23075.
  5. 2018 to 2020Several quantitative factors underperform, a stretch dubbed the “quant winter”; a recovery follows from 2021 (Wikipedia).

None of the four definitions on this page has a single date of invention. “Discretionary” and “narrative” investing describe what investors did long before anyone named them, so they sit outside this timeline rather than at its start.

Active as a whole cannot beat passive after costs Sharpe’s arithmetic, and what complicates it

Sharpe’s argument needs only addition. The market’s return is a weighted average of what passive and active money earn; passive money earns the market’s return by construction; so active money, taken as a whole, must earn it too — before costs. Active management costs more to run, so after costs the average active dollar must trail the average passive one, in any period. The goal of active investing is to beat the market, but the arithmetic says that only some active investors can, and only at the expense of other active investors.

What complicates it

The arithmetic is about the average, not about any one investor: some active investors do beat the market. Many academic studies find that actively managed US equity funds underperform after fees, but a 2019 paper in a journal run by the CFA Institute challenged that consensus (Wikipedia, “Active management”). Index funds also trade less: their turnover tends to be lower, and turnover has costs that come straight out of returns (Wikipedia, “Index fund”).

Who decides: discretionary or systematic The first of the two spectra inside active investing

  • Discretionary

    A person makes the final call

    • The decision is a judgement made at the time.
    • It can be swayed by emotion, is not easily back-tested and has less rigorous risk control (Wikipedia).
    • Our reading: the same freedom is what lets a person respond to something no rule anticipated.
  • Systematic

    Rules make the final call

    • The conditions are written in advance and followed; it ranges from slow trend following to high-frequency trading, and even includes passive index tracking (Wikipedia).
    • Because the rules are fixed, they can be tested against past data.
    • Rules found in past data can stop working: several quantitative factors underperformed from 2018 to 2020 (Wikipedia).

Where the reason comes from: narrative or quantitative The second spectrum, independent of the first

  • Narrative

    The reason to buy is a story

    • Shiller: people justify spending and investing with narratives, factual or not, and narratives spread like epidemics, with economic impact.
    • Our reading: a story can point at a change before any data shows it, and a story that spreads can also carry prices past what the numbers support.
  • Quantitative

    The reason to buy is numbers

    • Factor strategies target value ratios, momentum or low volatility through rules-based portfolio construction (Wikipedia).
    • Low-volatility securities have earned higher returns than high-volatility ones in most markets studied (Wikipedia).
    • Our reading: a pattern learnt from history says nothing about a change that has never happened before.

The two questions are independent. Wikipedia’s entry on systematic trading says it outright: quantitative techniques are used to value assets, “but the trading decision may be systematic or discretionary”. So a person can read the statements and work out a valuation by hand — numbers, decided by a person — and a fund can write a story, such as a technology theme, into fixed selection rules — a story, decided by rules. Quantitative funds are “often referred to as systematic funds” because the two ends so often go together, not because they are one thing.

How to place any active strategy Three questions, and what to hold loosely

  • Is it holding the whole market in the market’s proportions? If not, it is active, however little trading it involves.
  • Who makes the final call? Place it between a person and a fixed set of rules.
  • Where does the reason come from? Place it between a story about the future and numbers from the past.

Hold loosely

The two spectra are this article’s way of sorting active styles, built on the sources above rather than taken from a standard classification. A factor’s past premium is a finding about a period, not a promise. This is an explanation of concepts, not investment advice.

Quick notes

  1. Explainer

    Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

    Defined by what it is not, then sorted by two questions.

    Active investing1 / 6

  2. Definition

    Active is everything that is not passive

    • 100%of the market, in its own proportions: passive
    • < 100%or other proportions: active

    Active investing2 / 6

  3. Arithmetic

    After costs, the average active dollar trails

    • Before costs: active as a whole earns the market’s return.
    • After costs: it earns less than passive, in any period (Sharpe, 1991).

    Active investing3 / 6

  4. Spectrum 1

    Who decides

    EndStrengthWeakness
    DiscretionaryJudgement in the momentEmotion; hard to back-test
    SystematicDiscipline; testableRules can stop working

    Active investing4 / 6

  5. Spectrum 2

    Where the reason comes from

    EndLooks atExample
    NarrativeA story about the futureA technology theme
    QuantitativeNumbers from the pastValue, momentum, low volatility

    Active investing5 / 6

  6. Close

    Two independent questions

    A quantitative decision “may be systematic or discretionary”: place a strategy on both spectra, not one.

    Active investing6 / 6

  • William F. Sharpe, “The Arithmetic of Active Management”, Financial Analysts Journal, 1991
  • Robert J. Shiller, “Narrative Economics”, NBER Working Paper 23075, Jan 2017
  • Wikipedia, “Active management”
  • Wikipedia, “Systematic trading”
  • Wikipedia, “Quantitative fund”
  • Wikipedia, “Momentum investing”
  • Wikipedia, “Low-volatility anomaly”
  • Wikipedia, “Index fund”. All read 5 Nov 2026.

Reliable

Reliable, but with an interestWorth believing and reliableWeak on both, and used with careHonest, but thin

Worth believing

Each point is one source used, placed by two judgements on a six-step scale. Points carry no names: the chart shows the shape of the evidence, not a verdict on any publisher.

Versions

This document is rewritten when what it says has to change. Every version stays published at its own address.

  1. v0001 current

The current version is also at latest/.