Tratopedia
Side N繁中
Settings

Text size

Language

Theme

High contrast

Version

v1.230.2

The release this page was built from. It is what the service worker caches under.

Investing Styles · Active Investing · Passive Investing · Interactive ExplainerConcepts, backed by two reports of 5 Nov 2026

Investing styles, sorted

What does “passive investing” really mean?

Three questions about buying TSMC on a fixed schedule, then three pairs of terms that sort investing styles by their goal, by who makes the call, and by where the reason to buy comes from.

Backed by: Passive investing: the whole market, by its value · Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

Three questions Tap a question to open or close it.

Q1I believe in TSMC and buy it on a fixed monthly schedule. What is that called?

It’s called “stock saving” (存股) — more precisely, regular fixed-amount saving in TSMC.

In the strict sense it isn’t passive investing. Choosing only TSMC is itself active stock selection; only the execution is passive: no watching the market, no timing, holding for the long run.

Broken down
SelectionActive, and all on one stock (concentrated investing)Active
BuyingA fixed amount at regular intervals (pound-cost averaging)Passive
HoldingBuy and hold, never sellPassive

Watch out

A fixed schedule spreads only your timing risk, not the risk of the company itself. However strong TSMC is, it is still a single stock.

A middle way

To keep your faith in TSMC but spread the risk a little more, consider a market-cap-weighted ETF such as 0050 or 006208 — TSMC already carries a heavy weight inside them.

※ Concepts only, not investment advice.

Backed by: Passive investing: the whole market, by its value

Q2What counts as passive investing in the strict sense?

Strict passive investing has to meet both conditions at once:

  • What you buy

    • The whole market — no picking stocks yourself
    • Tracks an index, weighted by market capitalisation
    • Low fees, rarely changes holdings

    Closest to the ideal: a global market-cap ETF (such as VT).

  • How you buy

    • No market timing: don’t top up or pause because you feel bullish or bearish
    • Hold for the long term, don’t trade in and out
    • Rebalance by rule when the share/bond mix drifts
Grey areas
0050, 006208Near passiveThe tool is passive, but it buys only Taiwan, with a heavy TSMC weight.
High-dividend and thematic ETFsLeans activeThey track an index too, but one that picks its holdings by a rule — dividend yield, a theme — rather than holding the market by value, so they lean active.
Leveraged / inverse ETFsNot passiveShort-term trading tools; they don’t count as passive.

Check yourself

Tick what applies to see whether it counts as strictly passive. of 3: not strictly passive investing yet.All three: this is passive investing in the strict sense.

※ Concepts only, not investment advice.

Backed by: Passive investing: the whole market, by its value

Q3Why do people in Taiwan casually call active stock saving “passive investing”?

Mainly because, in everyday Taiwanese usage, “passive” has been borrowed to mean something else:

  1. 1It is contrasted with short-term trading, not with an indexTaiwanese retail investors often call day trading and swing trading “active”. By contrast, stock saving — buy, stop watching the screen, rarely trade — gets labelled “passive”.
  2. 2It gets mixed up with “passive income”People save stocks for the dividends, and dividends are often called “passive income”. Over time, “stock saving = passive investing” simply sounds right.
  3. 3A fixed schedule feels “automatic”Once the automatic debit is set up there is nothing to do, so it feels passive. But that only makes the execution passive; choosing TSMC or financial stocks is still active stock selection.
  4. 4Saving ETFs blurs the line furtherMany people save 0050 or 006208, which genuinely is close to passive investing. But the same wording is carried over to single stocks, so the terms get mixed up.
In short
Everyday “passive”Can’t be bothered to act
Academic “passive”No stock picking; buy the whole market

Backed by: Passive investing: the whole market, by its value

Three comparisons The first pair is the top-level split. The other two describe active investing from within — and each is a spectrum, not an either/or.

  • Investing

    Passive

    Goal: keep pace with the market

  • Investing

    Active

    Goal: beat the market

Backed by: Passive investing: the whole market, by its value · Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

Who decides

DiscretionarySystematic

Who decides: from discretionary to systematic.

Backed by: Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

Where the reason comes from

NarrativeQuantitative

Where the reason comes from: from narrative to quantitative.

Backed by: Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

Investing splits into passive and active by goal; active is further described by two independent spectra: who decides, from person to rules, and where the reason comes from, from story to numbers.

Backed by: Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

Red = person · Blue = rules · Orange = story · Green = numbers

Backed by: Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

Two independent spectra; most strategies sit somewhere in between.

Backed by: Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

Active vs passive Pair 1 · compares the goal

  • Active investing

    Goal: beat the market (or the index)

    • You or a fund manager pick stocks and time entries and exits, chasing excess returns. Fees and turnover are higher; performance may beat the market, or be thrashed by it.
  • Passive investing

    Goal: keep pace with the market (or the index), not beat it

    • Buy index ETFs that track the whole market, weighted by market capitalisation. No stock picking, no timing; hold for the long term. Low fees and little effort.

Backed by: Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from · Passive investing: the whole market, by its value

Active vs passive

The difference is the goal. Active wants to beat the market (or the index), so it has to pick stocks and time trades; passive thinks that is hard to do, so it simply buys the whole market. This is the top-level split — the next two pairs are both ways of dividing active investing.

Backed by: Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from · Passive investing: the whole market, by its value

Discretionary ↔ systematic Pair 2 · compares who makes the call

  • Discretionary investing

    A person makes the final call

    • Reads financial statements, industries and news, and buys or sells on experience. Can cope with the unexpected, but is easily swayed by emotion and bias.
  • Systematic investing

    Rules make the final call

    • Conditions are written in advance; when a signal appears, you act on it, with no improvising. Consistently disciplined and back-testable, but when the market changes, the model may stop working.

Backed by: Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

A spectrum, not a switch

Person decidesRules decide

Spectrum from discretionary to systematic: 1 pure gut feel; 2 judgement guided by a checklist; 3 rules, with a human able to override; 4 fully automated.1234
  1. 1 Pure gut feel
  2. 2 Judgement, guided by a checklist
  3. 3 Rules, with a human able to override
  4. 4 Fully automated, no one intervenes

Backed by: Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

Discretionary ↔ systematic

The difference is who decides. Discretionary relies on a person’s judgement in the moment — flexible, but prone to emotion; systematic follows rules — disciplined, but unable to adapt. It is not either/or: most investors mix the two in some proportion, and how the rules are set is ultimately decided by people anyway.

Backed by: Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

Narrative ↔ quantitative Pair 3 · compares where the reason comes from

  • Narrative investing

    The reason to buy is a story

    • For example: “AI will change the world, so buy the supply chain.” It can catch big trends before the data reflects them, but a story that sounds too good can have you chasing the top of a bubble.
  • Quantitative investing

    The reason to buy is numbers

    • For example P/E ratio, momentum and volatility, using statistics to find patterns. Less likely to be swept along by a story, but blind to changes that have never appeared in historical data.

Backed by: Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

A spectrum, not a switch

StoryNumbers

Spectrum from narrative to quantitative: 1 a story alone; 2 a story, sanity-checked against valuation; 3 a numbers screen, then a story to choose; 4 a statistical model alone.1234
  1. 1 A story alone
  2. 2 A story, sanity-checked against valuation
  3. 3 A numbers screen, then a story to choose
  4. 4 A statistical model alone

Backed by: Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

Narrative ↔ quantitative

The difference is where the reason to buy comes from, whoever makes the call. Narrative looks at a story about the future; quantitative looks at numbers from the past. This too is a matter of proportion, not a switch: quant often pairs with systematic investing, yet reading statements and working out valuations by hand is numbers-driven too. Ideally, each checks the other.

Backed by: Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

Two spectra, one plane Pairs 2 × 3

Who decides and where the reason comes from are separate spectra. Together they form a plane, and most real strategies sit somewhere inside it rather than in a corner.

StoryWhere the reason comes fromNumbers

Person decidesWho decidesRules decide

A plane of two spectra: across, where the reason comes from, from story to numbers; down, who decides, from person to rules. Five numbered examples sit on it.12345
  • Back a story on judgement
  • Read statements and work out valuations by hand
  • Turn a story into stock-selection rules
  • Rule-based statistical strategies
Examples
#ExampleWhere the reason comes fromWho decidesWhat it means
1Gut-feel theme buyerStory 90 : 10 NumbersPerson 92 : 8 RulesBuys whatever theme feels hot, on instinct.
2Saving TSMC (Q1)Story 75 : 25 NumbersPerson 45 : 55 RulesChose TSMC out of conviction (mostly story, some numbers), but buys on a fixed schedule (rules).
3Fundamental analystStory 35 : 65 NumbersPerson 80 : 20 RulesBuilds a valuation from the statements, then makes the final call personally.
4Rules-based thematicStory 70 : 30 NumbersPerson 15 : 85 RulesWrites a story (say, AI) into fixed selection rules and follows them.
5Quant fundStory 8 : 92 NumbersPerson 5 : 95 RulesStatistical signals, executed by rules with no one intervening.
How a position reads · Who decides
PositionWho decides
0–15almost entirely a person
20–40mostly a person, with some rules
45–55about half person, half rules
60–80mostly rules, with some judgement
85–100almost entirely rules
How a position reads · Where the reason comes from
PositionReason
0–15almost entirely a story
20–40mostly a story, with some numbers
45–55about half story, half numbers
60–80mostly numbers, with some story
85–100almost entirely numbers

Positions are illustrative, not measurements.

Backed by: Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

Content is a conceptual explanation, not investment advice.

Backed by: Passive investing: the whole market, by its value · Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

Quick notes

Versions

This document is rewritten when what it says has to change. Every version stays published at its own address.

  1. v0001 current

The current version is also at latest/.