Tratopedia
Side N繁中
Settings

Text size

Language

Theme

High contrast

Version

v1.230.2

The release this page was built from. It is what the service worker caches under.

Time Travel · Science Fiction · Television · Literature · ComparisonA novel of 1955 and two series to July 2026

Contains spoilers for all three endings

Rewrite, preserve or police: three agencies that run time

Science fiction keeps inventing an office that stands outside time and decides what happens inside it. Three of the best known are Eternity, from Isaac Asimov's 1955 novel The End of Eternity; the Time Variance Authority, from the Disney+ series Loki; and the Time Police, the fourth-dimensional enforcers of Rick and Morty. They share a headquarters beyond time and the look of a bureaucracy. They differ on what they want history to be: Eternity improves it, the TVA freezes it, and the Time Police do not care what it says so long as nobody breaks the rules. The two that resemble each other most, Eternity and the TVA, are often said to be related, and the evidence for that is thinner than the resemblance.

Three offices outside time Each as its own story presents it

  • 1955The End of Eternity published by Doubleday, later shortlisted for the Hugo
  • 2015The Time Police first appear in Rick and Morty
  • 2021Loki brings the TVA to Disney+
AgencyWhat it isWhere it comes from
EternityAn organisation outside time that makes small Reality Changes to improve human happiness. Its Technicians carry them out, under a council of senior Computers.Isaac Asimov, The End of Eternity, 1955
Time Variance AuthorityA bureaucracy outside time that guards the Sacred Timeline, arrests “variants” who stray from it and prunes their branches. Its staff are themselves variants who do not know it.Michael Waldron, Loki, Disney+, 2021 to 2023
Time PoliceFourth-dimensional beings who arrest people for misusing time technology and send them to Time Prison.Rick and Morty, Adult Swim, from 2015

Seventy years of offices outside time Publication and air dates

  1. 1955Asimov publishes The End of Eternity (Wikipedia).
  2. 25 Jan 1987A Soviet film of the novel, directed by Andrei Yermash, is released (Wikipedia).
  3. 26 Jul 2015“A Rickle in Time” introduces the Time Police (Wikipedia).
  4. 17 Nov 2019“The Old Man and the Seat”, written by Michael Waldron, airs on Rick and Morty (Wikipedia).
  5. 15 Dec 2019The Time Cops erase a species of snakes by killing its first tool-user (Wikipedia).
  6. 9 Jun 2021Loki premieres on Disney+ (Wikipedia).
  7. 14 Jul 2021He Who Remains is revealed as the TVA's creator (Wikipedia).
  8. 9 Nov 2023Loki ends with Loki weaving the timelines into a tree at the End of Time (Wikipedia).
  9. 2024In Deadpool & Wolverine, the TVA arrests one of its own agents, Mr. Paradox (Wikipedia).
  10. 24 May 2026The Time Police arrest Evil Morty after Rick tips them off (Wikipedia).
  11. 18 Dec 2026Avengers: Doomsday is scheduled, with Tom Hiddleston in the cast (Rotten Tomatoes).

Who gets to choose the future Our reading of the three plots, and its limits

Read side by side, the three agencies give three answers to one question: who should decide what history becomes. Eternity answers that experts should, and Asimov lets it fail on its own terms. Its people from the far future find that a humanity protected from every risk grows depressed and dies out, so the novel's last act is the minimum change that stops Eternity ever existing: “the end of Eternity – and the beginning of Infinity”. The TVA answers that one man should. Its staff are variants who do not know what they are, its Time-Keepers turn out not to be its makers, and the show ends not by abolishing the office but by putting Loki in it, holding every branch at once. The Time Police give no answer at all. They do not care what history says, only that nobody breaks the rules, and when a species of snakes travels in time too much they go back and kill its first tool-user. This is our reading of the plots, not a claim any of their makers has made.

  • RewriteEternity: change history in small steps to make people happier
  • PreserveThe TVA: keep one timeline and prune every branch
  • PoliceThe Time Police: punish misuse, whatever history says

What complicates it

The Time Police are a recurring joke rather than an argument, so setting them beside a novel and a drama risks reading too much into a gag. And the TVA's ending is open: it is expected back in Avengers: Doomsday, scheduled for 18 December 2026, which could change what the office is.

Is the TVA Asimov's Eternity? What is claimed and what is shown Each item graded by what supports it

QuestionWhat the record showsSource
Does anyone say Loki borrowed from Asimov?Wikipedia's article on the novel says the series “heavily borrowed ideas”: the bureaucracy, the single preserved reality, agents taken from pruned timelines, and an organisation that brings about its own founding. The passage cites no source.Wikipedia
What did the TVA's makers say inspired it?Michael Waldron named Blade Runner, Mad Men, Toy Story and Armageddon, and described the TVA's look as “Mad Men meets Blade Runner”. Neither account mentions Asimov.Screen Rant; SlashFilm
Who saw the likeness?Reviewers did. Cora Buhlert wrote after the first episode that she suspected the TVA exists outside time “just like Eternity” in Asimov's novel.Cora Buhlert
Is there any link between Loki and Rick and Morty?A personal one. Waldron wrote the Rick and Morty episode “The Old Man and the Seat” in 2019 before creating Loki. Nothing read here shows the Time Police shaped the TVA.Wikipedia
Whose influence on fiction is documented?Asimov's, on other writers. A critic noted that John Crowley's 1989 novella “Great Work of Time” shares the novel's outline, and Charles Stross has said his 2009 novella “Palimpsest” is effectively a rewrite of it. A Soviet film adaptation followed in 1987.Wikipedia

Which agency suits which reader What each does best, and what it costs

Eternity, for the ethics

Best at the hardest question: whether a well-meaning authority should be allowed to steer history at all. Its answer is no, and the novel earns it. The cost is a cool, puzzle-like book with little action.

The TVA, for the drama

Best at making a bureaucracy personal: staff who are victims of the office they serve, and a hero who takes its burden on rather than escaping it. The cost is that its ending is tied to a film franchise and may yet change.

The Time Police, for the satire

Best at showing how absurd the whole idea is, in about three short episodes. The cost is that it is a running gag, not a worked-out world.

  • Call the Eternity–TVA link a likeness, not an influence. The only passage asserting influence is uncited, and the makers' own lists leave Asimov out.
  • For documented influence, look at Crowley and Stross. Their debts to the novel are on the record.

Quick notes

  1. Comparison · contains spoilers

    Rewrite, preserve or police: three agencies that run time

    Asimov's Eternity, Loki's TVA and Rick and Morty's Time Police, side by side.

    Three time agencies1 / 7

  2. The three

    Who they are

    AgencyFromJob
    EternityNovel, 1955Make history happier
    TVALoki, 2021Keep one timeline
    Time PoliceRick and Morty, 2015Punish misuse

    Three time agencies2 / 7

  3. Shared

    What all three have

    • A headquarters outside time, reaching into it.
    • The look of a bureaucracy: councils, hunters, prisons.
    • A willingness to erase people, or a whole species, for order.

    Three time agencies3 / 7

  4. Different

    What each wants history to be

    Eternity

    Rewrite it, step by step, for human happiness.

    TVA

    Preserve one version and prune every branch.

    Time Police

    Do not care what it says; punish rule-breakers.

    Three time agencies4 / 7

  5. Endings

    How each one ends

    AgencyFate
    EternityNever existed: its founding is undone
    TVALoki takes the throne and holds every branch
    Time PoliceStill working, as of season 9 in 2026

    Three time agencies5 / 7

  6. Influence

    A likeness, not a proven debt

    Claimed

    Wikipedia says Loki heavily borrowed from Asimov, citing nothing.

    Documented

    Waldron cited Blade Runner and Mad Men, not Asimov, and wrote for Rick and Morty before Loki.

    Three time agencies6 / 7

  7. Which to choose

    One question, three answers

    • For the ethics: read The End of Eternity.
    • For the drama: watch both seasons of Loki.
    • For the satire: three Rick and Morty episodes.

    Three time agencies7 / 7

  • Wikipedia, “The End of Eternity”, “The End of Eternity (film)”, “A Rickle in Time”, “Rattlestar Ricklactica”, “Rick and Morty season 4”, “Rick and Morty season 9”, “Loki (TV series)”, “Loki season 1”, “For All Time. Always.”, “Glorious Purpose (Loki season 2)” and “Deadpool & Wolverine”
  • Erik Amaya, Rotten Tomatoes, 20 Jul 2026
  • Sandy Schaefer, SlashFilm, 19 Aug 2023
  • Sam Taylor, Screen Rant, 11 Jun 2021
  • Cora Buhlert, “Loki Meets ‘The Variant’”, 18 Jun 2021. All read 1 Nov 2026.

Reliable

Reliable, but with an interestWorth believing and reliableWeak on both, and used with careHonest, but thin

Worth believing

Each point is one source used, placed by two judgements on a six-step scale. Points carry no names: the chart shows the shape of the evidence, not a verdict on any publisher.

Versions

This document is rewritten when what it says has to change. Every version stays published at its own address.

  1. v0001 current

The current version is also at latest/.