Variant calling · Sequencing technology · Genomics · Machine Learning · Bioinformatics · Research BriefReview published 20 October 2026
A review in Nature Reviews Genetics
Small Variants in the Long-Read Era
A small variant is a one-letter change or a short insertion or deletion, under 50 base pairs, between a person’s genome and the reference. Short-read sequencing found most of them and missed the ones inside long repeats. A review by Zhenxian Zheng, Fritz Sedlazeck and Ruibang Luo argues that long reads and deep learning have changed how these variants are found, and that the headline accuracy now hides where the remaining errors are.
What Happened
A field moved to deep learning, and a review takes stock Published online in Nature Reviews Genetics on 20 October 2026; every figure below is the review’s own unless marked.
- >99.9%SNP F1 for deep-learning callers on PacBio HiFi, in high-confidence regions
- ~99%The same on Oxford Nanopore, where indels remain the weak spot
- <20%Indel performance in homopolymers longer than 11 bp
What is established
Long reads of 10–20 kb (PacBio HiFi) and over 100 kb (Oxford Nanopore) map into repeats that short reads of 150–300 bp cannot, and neural-network callers now lead on both platforms.
What is not
How accurate any caller is in centromeres, segmental duplications and long tandem repeats. The review calls it poorly characterised, because the truth sets there cover one sample.
Timeline
Eight years from the first deep-learning caller to the review Dates are publication years of the papers the review cites, read at PubMed where marked.
- 2018DeepVariant treats a pile of aligned reads as an image and classifies candidate sites with a convolutional network; the review calls it the first widely adopted deep-learning caller.
- 2019PacBio’s circular consensus reads (HiFi) are shown to combine long length with high accuracy; Clairvoyante, a multi-task network for single-molecule data, appears the same year.
- 2020–2021Clair (recurrent) and PEPPER-Margin-DeepVariant (haplotype-aware, for nanopore reads) follow.
- 31 Mar 2022The Telomere-to-Telomere consortium publishes T2T-CHM13, a gapless human genome adding nearly 200 million bases that the reference had left unfinished (PubMed).
- 2022Clair3 combines a fast summary model with a detailed read-level model; Zheng and Luo are among its authors.
- 10 May 2023The Human Pangenome Reference Consortium’s draft cuts small-variant discovery errors from short-read data by 34% against GRCh38 (PubMed).
- 2025A clinical laboratory validates HiFi genome sequencing for small variants, reporting SNV recall above 99.9% in GIAB high-confidence regions (PubMed); Oxford Nanopore’s Dorado adds a self-attention variant caller.
- 20 Oct 2026The review is published online in Nature Reviews Genetics.
The Argument
Calling is solved where it was easy, and open where it matters The review’s central claim, and what complicates it.
Zheng, Sedlazeck and Luo argue that small variant calling is no longer one task but a family of them. A germline variant sits at about 50% or 100% of reads, a de novo one needs both parents’ data, a mosaic one is usually under 30%, and a somatic one in a tumour can be anywhere from under 1% to 100%. Long reads help all four by phasing: reads are sorted by the parent they came from, so a real variant gathers on one haplotype while sequencing errors stay scattered. The headline figures, they write, come from GIAB high-confidence regions; in a PacBio data set about 75% of discordant indel calls sit in or beside homopolymer runs, and on the complete T2T-CHM13 reference the best caller’s recall fell to 95% for SNPs and 85% for indels in low-mappability and segmental-duplication regions.
- 93%Of newly benchmarked T2T-CHM13 variants that lie in highly complex regions with little ground truth
- 1Sample, HG002, behind the T2T truth sets, which is also used for training
- ~1.7×Higher raw-read indel error for Oxford Nanopore than PacBio in a T2T-HG002 benchmark
What complicates it: the authors build the tools
Luo’s group develops the Clair family that the review discusses throughout, and Zheng is first author of Clair3. The review says so through its own reference list rather than a statement, and its comparisons are of designs, not a ranking of products.
And one figure reads differently at its source
The review says about 8% of GRCh38, nearly 200 million bases, was inaccessible to short-read mapping. The T2T paper it cites describes that 8% as the part of the genome the reference had left unfinished. The two overlap, but they are not the same measurement.
What Others Add
Three ways to call, and what each costs The review’s comparison of strategies, checked against the primary papers it cites where they could be read.
| Strategy | Strength | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Linear reference | Mature, fast tools | Reference bias; fragile in repeats and structural variation |
| Assembly-based | Reaches up to 15% of the genome that mapping had called inaccessible, in T2T evaluations | About ten times the computing; weaker on homopolymer indels |
| Pangenome graph | About 34% fewer small-variant errors than GRCh38 in the HPRC draft, measured on short reads | Heavy computing; no stable coordinates for clinical reports |
Networks
Three designs, three limits
- Convolutional networks (DeepVariant, Clair3, PEPPER) read the read pile as an image; a fixed window makes distant links hard.
- Recurrent networks (Clair, Clair3, Medaka) read the sequence in both directions; they are sequential and slow.
- Self-attention (Dorado variant, ClairS-TO) weighs every position at once; its cost grows quickly with length.
Material
Each kind of sample brings its own noise
- Long-read DNA: systematic errors in repeats and homopolymers, and bias from gaps in the reference.
- Bulk RNA: allele-specific expression shifts the expected fraction, and RNA editing can pass for a variant.
- Single-cell RNA: sparse coverage and allelic dropout, with ambient RNA and doublets adding false positives.
Conclusion
The bottleneck moves from calling a variant to trusting it What the review settles, what it leaves open, and what it proposes.
Settled
In easy, high-confidence regions, long-read deep-learning callers are accurate enough for clinical use, and a clinical laboratory has validated HiFi sequencing on that basis.
Open
Accuracy where it matters clinically. A pathogenic indel in an RPGR homopolymer or a paralogue-confounded variant in SMN1 barely moves an overall F1 score, yet can decide whether a patient receives a diagnosis.
- Read an accuracy figure with its regions. A number above 99.9% describes GIAB high-confidence regions, not the whole genome.
- Ask which reads a pangenome result was measured on. The HPRC draft’s 34% comes from short-read data.
- Treat hard-region benchmarks as provisional. They rest on one sample that callers are also trained on, so no held-out test yet exists.
Quick notes
- Zhenxian Zheng, Fritz J. Sedlazeck and Ruibang Luo, ‘Small variant calling in the era of long-read sequencing’, Nature Reviews Genetics, published online 20 Oct 2026, doi:10.1038/s41576-026-01020-7, with its Crossref record
- Nurk and colleagues, ‘The complete sequence of a human genome’, Science 376, 2022
- Liao and colleagues, ‘A draft human pangenome reference’, Nature 617, 2023
- Hammond and colleagues, ‘Analytical validation of germline small variant detection using long-read HiFi genome sequencing’, Genome Research 35, 2025. The three cited papers were read at PubMed. All read 21 Oct 2026.
Reliable
Worth believing
Sharing a subject
- Sequencing a Genome at Home — The Full ONT MinION WorkflowGenomics · Sequencing technology
- Dorado v4 to v6 — What Changed, How Much, and Whether It Was GoodGenomics · Sequencing technology
- The Rise of Biomedical Foundation Models — 220 Models SurveyedMachine Learning
- The Filters That Decide What a Single-Cell Experiment SawBioinformatics
- Seven sequence aligners, three jobsBioinformatics
- Six single-cell analysis platforms, comparedBioinformatics
Sharing a source domain
- The Rise of Biomedical Foundation Models — 220 Models Surveyednature.com · nih.gov
- Meal Sequencing — Vegetables Before Starchnih.gov
- Dark Marks on Clothing — Identifying and Removing Themnih.gov
- Sequencing a Genome at Home — The Full ONT MinION Workflownature.com
- Dorado v4 to v6 — What Changed, How Much, and Whether It Was Goodnih.gov
- The Polyamory Words, and the One Nobody Can Datenih.gov
- The Electron, to Thirteen Digitsnature.com
- Three Cuts Into the Uncuttablenature.com
- Not a Ladder, a Palimpsestnature.com
- The Dying, Not the Bereavednih.gov
- The Colour Is the Vitaminnih.gov
- The Switch Nobody Has Foundnih.gov
- The Sun Does Not Kill Themnih.gov
- Decades Rather Than Yearsnature.com
- Dairy in East and Southeast Asianih.gov
- Seven sequence aligners, three jobsnih.gov
- 794 million CRISPR spacers, and what they say about phagesnature.com