Tratopedia
繁中
Settings

Text size

Language

Theme

High contrast

Version

v1.230.2

The release this page was built from. It is what the service worker caches under.

Slide deck

Back

What Actually Threatens a Digital Photo Archive

A photo survives only if four things hold: working media, untouched bytes, a readable format, and a provider still in business. In one study, a single flipped bit made a compressed file unreadable 99.8% of the time — and a JPEG is compressed by default.

  1. Digital Preservation · Research Brief

    What Actually Threatens a Digital Photo Archive

    A photo survives only if four things hold: working media, untouched bytes, a readable format, and a provider still in business.

    What threatens a photo archive1 / 15

  2. Four failure modes, not one

    Four points of failure, each independent of the other three

    Each fails in its own way, on its own timeline, and a backup copy does not defend against all four.

    The medium

    Has a rated life, and it is shorter unpowered than most people assume.

    The bytes

    Even a working drive can quietly return the wrong bytes, and a copy alone does not catch it.

    The format

    Intact bytes still need some piece of software that can read them.

    The provider

    Needs no error and no malice to remove your access — a business decision is enough.

    What threatens a photo archive2 / 15

  3. The figures

    Four things had to go wrong, and each one did, somewhere, on the record

    • 1 in 1,500files found silently corrupted in an ~8.7 TB CERN audit, 2007
    • 99.8%chance one flipped bit made a compressed file unreadable, CERN 2007
    • 1.36%annualised hard-drive failure rate across Backblaze’s fleet, 2025
    • 15 GBshared free quota new Google Photos uploads now count against

    What threatens a photo archive3 / 15

  4. 1 · The medium

    Retention is rated, and it gets worse with wear and heat

    • 3 monthsminimum retention at 40°C that JEDEC requires of an enterprise SSD at the end of its rated life, as IBM describes it
    • 2 weekspowered on for every two months a system is shut down, IBM recommends
    • ~10 → ~3 yearsrough retention by NAND type, from SLC down toward the TLC cells common in consumer drives, per Starline
    • 4 monthsStarline’s worst case: a heavily used drive at 40°C, end of life, can start losing data this soon

    Vendors, not the standard

    JEDEC’s own specification document (JESD218) could not be opened at any address tried; these are vendors describing what the standard requires, not the standard itself.

    What threatens a photo archive4 / 15

  5. 2 · The bytes

    One flipped bit can make a compressed file unreadable

    • 22 of 33,700files mismatched their recorded checksums, about 8.7 TB checked, CERN 2007 — one bad file in 1,500
    • 99.8%of the time, one flipped bit made a whole compressed file unreadable in CERN’s tests

    A JPEG is compressed by default

    A photograph saved as a JPEG is exactly the case the finding describes.

    One centre, one period

    The figures describe one research computing centre’s infrastructure in 2007, with no comparable successor study found: an illustration that silent corruption is real, not a current rate for any device.

    What threatens a photo archive5 / 15

  6. 2 · The bytes

    Two open filesystems checksum every block by default

    WhereWhat checks the bytes
    OpenZFSA checksum for every block on write, verified again on read; a bad block repaired automatically where a mirror or RAID copy exists; a scheduled scrub of the whole pool.
    BtrfsChecksums data and metadata by default, with CRC32C as the default.
    Phone, external drive, consumer cloud photosNeither filesystem ships by default, so most personal photo storage has no equivalent check running at all.

    What threatens a photo archive6 / 15

  7. 3 · The format

    Disclosure is what makes a format outlive its own decade

    Whether a file stays legible to some piece of software is a separate question from whether its bytes are intact.

    FormatWhat the record shows
    JPEGISO/IEC 10918-1, reconfirmed current in 2017; graded “fully disclosed” and “very widely adopted”; two patent disputes resolved against the claimants.
    Camera RAWMost manufacturers publish no equivalent specification for their own RAW format.
    DNGAdobe’s openly published specification, v1.6.0.0, Dec 2021; graded “fully documented”, with a public patent licence; used in Apple ProRAW.

    What threatens a photo archive7 / 15

  8. 4 · The provider

    A business decision is enough

    1. 2020Google announces it will end unlimited free “High quality” storage for Google Photos, effective the following June.
    2. 2021The Google Photos change takes effect: only photos and videos uploaded in High quality before 1 June remain exempt from the shared 15 GB free quota.

    What threatens a photo archive8 / 15

  9. 4 · The provider

    A company can be sold, spun off or wound down

    The Incydr dates are corroborated, not verified at Code42’s own source.

    1. 2017Code42 discontinues CrashPlan for Home, telling customers to migrate before the consumer service closes; Backblaze and Carbonite are named as the obvious alternatives.
    2. 2022Code42 spins its backup business off to Mill Point Capital as the independent CrashPlan Group; Code42 keeps its Incydr product line and is later folded into Mimecast.
    3. 1 Jan–31 Dec 2026Code42’s Incydr Backup Add-on stops accepting new orders on 1 January and reaches end of life on 31 December, after which archived backups are deleted.

    What threatens a photo archive9 / 15

  10. The record

    What is established, and how firmly

    StandingWhat the record shows
    ConfirmedThe CERN 2007 audit; Backblaze’s 2025 drive statistics; the Google Photos quota change; the end of CrashPlan for Home; NDSA’s Levels 2.1; SoftMaker’s 3-2-1 advice.
    Confirmed but not verifiable hereCode42’s Incydr Backup Add-on: no new orders from 1 January 2026, end of life on 31 December 2026, archived backups deleted after.
    UnconfirmedThat providers in general have “closed up shop, changed their terms or scrapped their free offerings” over roughly fifteen years — a claim made without further names or dates.

    What threatens a photo archive10 / 15

  11. What others add

    Preservation is treated as a maturity ladder, not a yes/no

    The 3-2-1 rule

    Three copies, on two kinds of media, one kept off-site — SoftMaker’s advice for personal photo collections, Aug 2026.

    Levels of Digital Preservation

    First published 2013, Version 2.0 in 2019, Version 2.1 in March 2026, which adds environmental sustainability without changing the levels. Its detailed matrix could not be read, so its staged criteria are not reproduced here.

    What threatens a photo archive11 / 15

  12. What to do · 1 of 2

    None of the four defences substitutes for another

    • Spread copies across more than one kind of medium and more than one vendor, not just more than one drive.
    • Check the copies, not just their existence: open a handful of files from each backup on a schedule.
    • Where the storage is under your own control, such as a home NAS, use a filesystem that checksums on write and scrubs on a schedule (OpenZFS, Btrfs).

    What threatens a photo archive12 / 15

  13. What to do · 2 of 2

    None of the four defences substitutes for another

    • Keep at least one copy in an openly published, widely supported format: JPEG for a finished photo, DNG rather than a camera’s proprietary RAW for the original.
    • Do not let any one provider be the only place a copy exists, and read what a free tier actually promises before relying on it.

    What threatens a photo archive13 / 15

  14. Caveats

    What to hold loosely

    The CERN rates

    One research computing centre’s infrastructure from 2007, with no comparably detailed successor study found: an illustration that silent corruption is real and compression raises its cost, not a current number for any specific device.

    The Incydr timeline

    Corroborated rather than independently verified at its own source, which returned a block on every attempt to open it.

    The SSD retention figures

    JEDEC’s own specification (JESD218) could not be opened; the figures are IBM and Starline describing what the standard requires.

    What threatens a photo archive14 / 15

  15. What to remember

    A photo needs four things to keep going right, not one

    Working media, checked bytes, a readable format and a provider that is still there next year are four separate conditions, each with its own history of failing.

    Not automatic, not exotic

    Meeting all four is a handful of specific, checkable choices, repeated.

    What threatens a photo archive15 / 15