Tratopedia
繁中
Settings

Text size

Language

Theme

High contrast

Version

v1.230.2

The release this page was built from. It is what the service worker caches under.

Slide deck

Back

Three Legal Systems: Malaysia, Singapore and Taiwan

Malaysia and Singapore build law from precedent, Taiwan from codes, but rights differ for other reasons: who may take a law or a judgment to court, and whether detention needs a judge. Only Taiwan lets a person challenge a final judgment itself as unconstitutional.

  1. Comparative law · law as read 15 October 2026

    Malaysia, Singapore and Taiwan: three legal systems

    How the law is built, which courts apply it, and what a person can do with it against the state.

    Malaysia: common law, Islamic law and native custom, in a federation · Singapore: common law, one legislature · Taiwan: civil-law codes, a single constitutional court. A comparison, not legal advice on any case.1 / 34

  2. Summary

    Three conclusions

    • Legal family

      It decides how the law looks

      • Taiwan: a Civil Code in five books and a Criminal Code with a general and a specific part.
      • Malaysia and Singapore: no civil code; precedent plus statutes, and criminal codes on Indian models.
    • Routes

      Rights depend on who can get to a court

      • Taiwan: a person can challenge a final judgment itself; citizen judges; arrest to court within 24 hours.
      • Singapore: mandatory death for drug trafficking above set amounts, caning, detention without trial.
      • Malaysia: religion decides which family law and which court apply.
    • Reforms

      Each is moving, in its own direction

      • Taiwan: review of judgments (2022), citizen judges (2023), the death-penalty judgment (2024).
      • Singapore: section 377A repealed and Article 156 added (2022).
      • Malaysia: mandatory death ended (2023); Nik Elin (2024); SIS Forum (2025).

    Not a ranking: the three are not moving along one scale2 / 34

  3. Contents

    Eight parts

    • Overview: legal origins, constitutions, courts, precedent, lay judges
    • Malaysia: federalism, Islamic and civil courts, native courts
    • Singapore: one legislature, localised common law, the Syariah Court
    • Civil law: a code against precedent and statutes
    • Criminal law: codes, the death penalty, detention
    • Rights in practice: limits, review, defendants, family, religion
    • Side by side: two summary tables
    • Conclusion, and what could not be checked

    3 / 34

  4. 1 · Overview

    Where each legal system comes from

    • Malaysia

      Common law, with limits

      • The Civil Law Act 1956 applies English common law and equity as they stood on 7 April 1956 in West Malaysia; Sabah and Sarawak received English law by ordinances of 1951 and 1949.
      • Islamic law and native custom apply in their own fields.
    • Singapore

      Common law, made local

      • The Application of English Law Act keeps the common law that was part of Singapore law before 12 November 1993, as local circumstances allow.
      • English statutes apply only if listed in its First Schedule; a local Act prevails over an inconsistent one.
    • Taiwan

      Civil law, in codes

      • The law is found first in codes: the Civil Code, the Criminal Code and the two procedure codes.
      • English law was never received.

    4 / 34

  5. 1 · Overview

    Constitutions and who reviews laws against them

    ItemMalaysiaSingaporeTaiwan
    Reviewing courtOrdinary courts; the Federal Court at the topOrdinary courts; the Court of Appeal at the topOne Constitutional Court; fifteen seats
    How a person raises itIn a case; a claim that a legislature lacked power needs a Federal Court judge’s leaveIn a case or by judicial reviewAfter exhausting appeals, against the final judgment or the law it applied, within six months
    Basic structureAccepted: judicial review cannot be amended away (2018)Rejected by the High CourtNot covered here
    AmendmentTwo-thirds of ParliamentTwo-thirds of MPs; a few articles by referendumLegislative proposal, then a referendum passed by more than half of all voters

    5 / 34

  6. 1 · Overview · Taiwan

    The route is open, and most who take it are turned away

    • 5,681New petitions, 4 Jan 2022 to the end of 2023
    • 11.18%Petition acceptance ratio in 2023, the court’s own measure; 9.66% for individuals
    • 83.8%Cases ended in 2024 that were dismissed as inadmissible: 1,031 of 1,231 (91.82% in 2023)

    What changed

    Interpretations became judgments, and a person may now argue that a court’s final judgment itself is unconstitutional. Filing needs no lawyer; an oral hearing does.

    The 2024–25 dispute

    An amendment passed on 20 December 2024 required ten justices to deliberate and nine to strike a law down; eight were in office, and PTS reports no judgment for more than 400 days. On 19 December 2025 five justices struck the amendment down; three called that judgment void.

    The 11.18% and the 91.82% are not complements: one divides by petitions, the other by cases ended6 / 34

  7. 1 · Overview

    Court systems

    • Malaysia

      One federal judiciary, two parallel ones

      • Magistrates’ and Sessions Courts; two High Courts; the Court of Appeal; the Federal Court.
      • State syariah courts, for Muslims only.
      • Native courts in Sabah and Sarawak.
    • Singapore

      Restructured in 2021

      • From 2 January 2021 the High Court has a General Division, which includes the international commercial court, and an Appellate Division.
      • A further appeal from the Appellate Division needs the Court of Appeal’s leave; all criminal appeals from the General Division go to the Court of Appeal.
      • A Syariah Court for Muslim family matters.
    • Taiwan

      Several separate court systems

      • Ordinary courts: district, high and supreme, in principle three instances.
      • Separate administrative courts.
      • The Constitutional Court.

    7 / 34

  8. 1 · Overview

    Precedent, and who sits in judgment

    • Precedent

      Binding in two, advisory in one

      • Malaysia and Singapore: higher courts bind lower ones; the reasons of a judgment are law.
      • Taiwan: selected Supreme Court precedents lost their binding force in 2019 and now weigh as any other Supreme Court judgment; grand chambers settle conflicting views.
    • Lay judges

      Only Taiwan puts citizens on the bench

      • Malaysia ended jury trials on 1 January 1995; Singapore in 1969.
      • Taiwan: three judges and six citizen judges since 1 January 2023 for intentional offences causing death; from 1 January 2026 also offences with a ten-year minimum. Juvenile and drug-statute cases excluded.
      • First year: 108 cases received, 16 decided, 15 returned to ordinary procedure, 77 still pending.

    8 / 34

  9. 2 · Malaysia

    Federalism and the division of legislative power

    Ninth ScheduleWho legislatesWhat it covers
    Federal ListParliamentIncluding criminal law
    State ListState assembliesIslamic law and the personal and family law of Muslims, including offences against Islam, but not matters on the Federal List
    Concurrent ListBothFederal law prevails where the two conflict (Article 75)

    Thirteen states and three federal territories9 / 34

  10. 2 · Malaysia

    Islamic courts and civil courts

    1. 2018Indira Gandhi: a child’s conversion without both parents’ consent is quashed; judicial review is part of the basic structure.
    2. 9 Feb 2024Nik Elin (8–1): 16 Kelantan provisions, among them incest and sexual harassment, are void as matters for Parliament; two survive.
    3. 19 Jun 2025SIS Forum (3–1): Selangor’s 2014 fatwa binds individuals, not a company, which cannot profess a religion.

    The limits

    Syariah courts have jurisdiction over Muslims only, and their criminal penalties are capped at three years, RM5,000 or six strokes. The Federal Court has framed its rulings as questions of which legislature may act, not of Islamic doctrine.

    The boundary is still moving: the reactions to both rulings are on the rights slides10 / 34

  11. 2 · Malaysia

    Native courts in Sabah and Sarawak

    • Sabah

      Native Courts Enactment 1992

      • Three levels: Native Court, District Native Court, Native Court of Appeal.
      • Section 9: no jurisdiction in anything within the syariah courts’ or the civil courts’ jurisdiction.
    • Sarawak

      Native Courts Ordinance 1992

      • Cases on native law and custom, and disputes over native customary rights to land.
      • Does not apply to natives professing Islam, except in cases on Malay custom and some listed matters.

    So Malaysia runs three court systems side by side: civil, syariah and native11 / 34

  12. 3 · Singapore

    One legislature, a local common law, and a Syariah Court

    • Parliament

      No states

      • All legislative power sits with Parliament.
      • The Constitution is the supreme law; most of it amends with two-thirds of MPs.
    • Common law

      Cut loose in 1993

      • English common law is kept as it stood before 12 November 1993; later English developments are not automatic.
    • Syariah Court

      Personal law only

      • Muslim marriage and divorce under the Administration of Muslim Law Act; no criminal jurisdiction; made by Parliament, not by states.

    12 / 34

  13. 4 · Civil law · Taiwan

    The Civil Code in five books

    BookArticlesWhat it holds
    General Principles1–152Persons, things, juristic acts, time limits; majority at 18
    Obligations153–756-9Contract, tort, unjust enrichment, and the named contracts
    Rights in rem757–966Ownership, security interests, possession
    Family967–1137Marriage, parents and children, guardianship, support
    Succession1138–1225Heirs, wills, and the reserved share

    General rules first, specific ones after: the general part applies to every book13 / 34

  14. 4 · Civil law · Taiwan

    Statutes beside the code

    • Consumers

      Consumer Protection Act

      • A business answers for unsafe goods or services; showing it was not at fault only lets the court reduce the damages.
      • Punitive damages up to five times the loss for intentional harm.
    • The state

      State Compensation Act

      • The state pays for officials’ unlawful acts done intentionally or negligently, and for defects in public facilities.
    • Marriage

      The J.Y. 748 Implementation Act

      • Same-sex marriage since 2019, inside the civil-law system rather than as an amendment to the code.

    14 / 34

  15. 4 · Civil law · Malaysia and Singapore

    No civil code: precedent, plus selected statutes

    AreaMalaysiaSingapore
    Gap-fillerEnglish common law and equity as at 7 April 1956 (West Malaysia)English common law as at 12 November 1993, adapted locally
    ContractA contract statute on the Indian model, with the common law behind itCommon law, with English statutes kept only where listed
    LandNational Land Code 1965 in West Malaysia, a Torrens register; land is a state matterNot covered here
    FamilyState Islamic family law for Muslims; a civil regime for othersMuslim law for Muslims; the Women’s Charter for others, with divorce by mutual agreement since 1 July 2024

    Further civil-law detail for the two is not covered here: it could not be traced to a source15 / 34

  16. 4 · Civil law

    Two ways to find a right

    • Taiwan

      System first, cases after

      • The code is the starting point; rights are read from its articles.
      • One civil law for everyone; family and succession do not split by religion.
    • Malaysia and Singapore

      Rules built case by case

      • Rights are spread across judgments and statutes, and often need case research to pin down.
      • Family and succession split by religion.

    16 / 34

  17. 5 · Criminal law · Taiwan

    The Criminal Code, and the rights of the accused

    • General part

      Articles 1–99

      • The rules every offence shares: intent and negligence, attempt, accomplices, sentencing.
      • Principal punishments: death, life, a fixed term, short detention, a fine.
    • Specific part

      Articles 100–363

      • Offences grouped by the interest they protect, each defined in the abstract with its range of punishment.
    • Procedure

      Code of Criminal Procedure

      • The accused must be told they may stay silent; they are presumed innocent until convicted.
      • A defence lawyer may be present at questioning; pre-trial detention is two months at a time.

    17 / 34

  18. 5 · Criminal law · Taiwan

    The death penalty: kept, and fenced in

    • 20 September 2024: constitutional only for the most serious intentional killings, with direct, general or alternative intent, completed.
    • A unanimous bench at every level; oral argument and a defence lawyer at the third instance; a lawyer present at questioning.
    • No death sentence for a defendant whose capacity was markedly reduced at the time, or who cannot defend themselves at trial; no execution of someone lacking the capacity to undergo it.
    • The 1999 text of article 348(1), which made death the only penalty for killing a kidnap victim, is unconstitutional; the current text already allows life.
    • 1Execution in 2025, the first after the judgment, on 16 January
    • 34Awaiting execution, September 2026

    18 / 34

  19. 5 · Criminal law · Malaysia

    The end of mandatory death, and what it did

    • 1,337 → 140On death row before the reform, and on 22 January 2025 (official figures)
    • 854Commuted in the temporary review: 761 men and 93 women, 91% of applicants
    • 43Death sentences the Federal Court affirmed on that review, all men; none for drugs at the time
    • From 4 July 2023: death or 30 to 40 years with at least 12 strokes, at the judge’s discretion; death removed for some offences not causing death.
    • The Federal Court ended its temporary review on 29 October 2024 after 936 people; with the Court of Appeal, at least 1,016 sentences were commuted.
    • Civil courts may order whipping, but not for women or men over 50.

    Before the reform: 11 or 12 mandatory-death offences, by different government counts. Commutation figures come from court registries via Amnesty International19 / 34

  20. 5 · Criminal law · Malaysia

    Preventive detention: a power under review

    • The Act

      Security Offences (Special Measures) Act 2012

      • Section 4(5): a senior police officer may extend detention to 28 days without bringing the suspect before a magistrate.
      • Section 13: no bail for some offences.
    • The review

      Ordered, recommended, not yet legislated

      • February 2025: the Prime Minister orders a review.
      • 3 December 2025: a parliamentary committee recommends reviewing the 28 days and the definitions of offences, and restoring courts’ discretion over remand, bail and trial.
      • The human-rights commission proposed seven days, extendable only by a court; the Malaysian Bar wants repeal.

    No amending bill was found in the sources read20 / 34

  21. 5 · Criminal law · Singapore

    The mandatory death penalty and caning remain central

    • 17Executions in 2025, 15 for drug offences
    • 16+Executions for drug offences in 2026, to 18 August
    • Trafficking more than 15 g of diamorphine, 250 g of methamphetamine or 500 g of cannabis may carry the mandatory death penalty.
    • A judge may choose life with caning only if the accused was merely a courier and the prosecution certifies substantive assistance.
    • On 14 August 2025 the President granted clemency to a man sentenced to death for drug trafficking.
    • Caning: not for women, men over 50, or men under sentence of death.

    Execution counts are those of UN human-rights experts21 / 34

  22. 5 · Criminal law · Singapore

    Detention without trial, protected by the Constitution

    • CLTPA

      Criminal Law (Temporary Provisions) Act

      • Enacted 1955; extended for the fifteenth time, to 20 October 2029.
      • Ministerial orders of up to 12 months, extendable by the President; for secret societies and criminal syndicates.
      • Each order goes to an advisory committee chaired by a Supreme Court judge; detainees may have lawyers; a third committee reviews detention beyond ten years.
      • 100 detained at the end of 2024, 99 of them linked to secret societies.
    • The Constitution

      Articles 9(6) and 149

      • Article 9(6) keeps a pre-Constitution detention law valid despite the liberty guarantees; Article 149 does the same for the Internal Security Act.

    The government: needed where witnesses fear reprisal. Critics in Parliament asked whether it still is22 / 34

  23. 5 · Criminal law

    How the penal codes are laid out

    AspectMalaysia and SingaporeTaiwan
    OriginIndian models from British ruleContinental codes
    StructureChapters in sequence, general explanations and exceptions near the frontA general part (articles 1–99) and a specific part (100–363)
    PunishmentsDeath, imprisonment, caning, finesDeath, life, a fixed term, short detention, fines; no caning

    How the two older codes illustrate their sections is not covered: no source read describes it23 / 34

  24. 6 · Rights in practice

    What the constitutions guarantee, and how they allow limits

    RightMalaysiaSingaporeTaiwan
    LibertyArticle 149 allows special laws against subversion and threats to public orderArticle 9(6) and Article 149 save detention laws from the liberty guaranteesArticle 8: to a court within 24 hours; limits only by law and only where necessary (article 23)
    SpeechArticle 10: citizens only; Parliament may restrictArticle 14: citizens only; restrictions Parliament “considers necessary or expedient”Limits must pass the necessity test of article 23
    Religion of a childArticle 12(4) read in 2018 to require both parents’ consentNot covered hereNot covered here
    MarriageNot covered hereArticle 156 shields laws defining marriage as between a man and a womanSame-sex marriage by statute since 2019

    Two of the three let Parliament decide how far a right may be limited; the third asks whether the limit is necessary24 / 34

  25. 6 · Rights in practice

    Can a person bring a law, or a judgment, before the Constitution?

    • Taiwan

      Directly

      • After exhausting appeals, against the final judgment or the law it applied.
      • Most are dismissed: 83.8% of cases ended in 2024; and the court’s quorum is disputed.
    • Malaysia

      Inside a case

      • Raised in litigation or judicial review; a claim that a legislature lacked power needs a Federal Court judge’s leave, the route Nik Elin took.
      • Religious cases first meet the line between civil and syariah courts.
    • Singapore

      Parliament has the last word

      • Raised in litigation or judicial review, with sufficient interest.
      • Section 377A was repealed by Parliament, which amended the Constitution in the same sitting to shield the definition of marriage.

    25 / 34

  26. 6 · Rights in practice

    Defendants’ rights

    RightMalaysiaSingaporeTaiwan
    Before a judge24 hours ordinarily; up to 28 days under the security-offences actMinisterial detention without trial under the CLTPAWithin 24 hours (Constitution, article 8)
    Silence and a lawyerNot covered hereNot covered hereTold of the right to silence; a lawyer may attend questioning
    Presumption of innocenceNot covered hereStatutory presumptions in drug cases, which UN experts criticiseWritten into the Code of Criminal Procedure
    Lay judgesNone since 1995None since 1969Citizen judges since 2023
    PunishmentDiscretionary death; caningMandatory death for drug trafficking above set amounts; caningDeath fenced in by the 2024 judgment; no caning

    A cell no source read supports is marked, not filled26 / 34

  27. 6 · Rights in practice

    Marriage and family

    • Taiwan

      The widest recognition of the three

      • Same-sex marriage registered since 24 May 2019.
      • Joint adoption of unrelated children passed on 16 May 2023.
      • Partners from countries that do not recognise it may register, except mainland Chinese partners; since 19 September 2024 cross-strait couples married in a third place may register.
    • Singapore

      Decriminalised, and the definition shielded

      • Section 377A repealed on 29 November 2022.
      • Article 156: Parliament may define and protect marriage; laws defining it as a man and a woman cannot be struck down under Part 4.
      • The government: the article does not write the definition into the Constitution.
    • Malaysia

      Split by religion

      • Muslims under state Islamic family law and syariah courts; others under a civil regime.
      • A minor’s conversion needs both parents’ consent (Federal Court, 2018).

    27 / 34

  28. 6 · Rights in practice · Malaysia

    How religion decides legal position

    • Which family and succession law, and which court, applies.
    • Whether state Islamic offences apply at all: syariah courts try Muslims only.
    • Whether a fatwa binds: individuals yes, a company no (SIS Forum, 2025).

    Two published positions

    The Chief Justice in Nik Elin: the case was about which legislature may act, not the position of Islamic law. The SIS Forum dissent, backed by the state Islamic council: the fatwa can bind the company and the dispute belongs in the syariah court.

    28 / 34

  29. 6 · Rights in practice

    Detention without a court: where the three differ most

    • Taiwan

      A court within 24 hours

      • The Constitution requires an arrested person to be brought to a court within 24 hours, and lets anyone ask a court to order the person produced.
    • Singapore

      Written into the Constitution

      • Ministerial detention under the CLTPA, and the Internal Security Act, both saved from the liberty guarantees.
    • Malaysia

      Under review

      • Up to 28 days without a magistrate under the security-offences act; a review is open and no bill has been seen.

    29 / 34

  30. 7 · Side by side

    Summary one: structure and codes

    ItemMalaysiaSingaporeTaiwan
    Legal familyCommon law + Islamic law + native customCommon law + Muslim personal lawCivil law
    StateFederation: 13 states, 3 federal territoriesUnitaryUnitary
    ReviewDiffuse; Federal Court; basic structure acceptedDiffuse; Court of Appeal; basic structure rejected by the High CourtCentralised; Constitutional Court; review of judgments
    Civil codeNoneNoneFive books
    Religious courtsState syariah courts, with criminal jurisdictionSyariah Court, personal law onlyNone
    Native courtsSabah and SarawakNoneNone

    30 / 34

  31. 7 · Side by side

    Summary two: rights and remedies

    ItemMalaysiaSingaporeTaiwan
    Lay judgesNoneNoneCitizen judges since 2023
    Death penaltyKept; mandatory form ended 2023Kept; mandatory for drugs above set amounts; 17 executed in 2025Kept; fenced in 2024; 1 executed in 2025
    CaningYesYesNo
    Detention without a courtUp to 28 days; under reviewCLTPA and the Internal Security ActCourt within 24 hours
    Same-sex couplesNot covered hereDecriminalised 2022; Article 156Marriage 2019; joint adoption 2023
    Family and successionSplit by religion and native statusSplit by religionOne Civil Code

    31 / 34

  32. 7 · Side by side

    What the three share

    • A written constitution declared to be the supreme law.
    • A death penalty still in the law, narrowed in Malaysia and Taiwan, not in Singapore.
    • Malaysia and Singapore: common-law method and penal, procedure and evidence codes on Indian models.

    32 / 34

  33. 8 · Conclusion

    Conclusions

    • The legal family is the starting point, not the whole story. What decides rights is how widely they may be limited, who can bring a case before the Constitution, and how legislature and courts divide the last word.
    • Taiwan has the most direct individual routes — review of judgments, a necessity test, citizen judges, a court within 24 hours — and the court at their centre has a disputed quorum. Filling the vacancies is the remedy scholars name.
    • Singapore lets Parliament decide: on the death penalty, caning, detention and marriage, the state’s judgment prevails, and changes come by statute.
    • Malaysia made the largest recent penal reform of the three and its Federal Court polices the federal–state line; religion still decides family law and the detention review is unfinished.
    • In practice: for Taiwan read the code and the court’s judgments; for Singapore the statute and the appellate cases; for Malaysia establish religion and state first.

    33 / 34

  34. Limits

    What could not be checked, and is therefore not claimed

    SubjectWhy it is absent or qualified
    The legal professionsAdmission, examinations and senior ranks in all three: no source read, so they are not covered.
    Contract, property, successionIslamic succession shares, will limits and the compensation case: not read, so not covered.
    Administrative remedies and legal aidOnly Taiwan’s State Compensation Act was read; it appears with the civil law, and the rest is not covered.
    Counts from NGOs and UN expertsMalaysia’s commutations and Singapore’s executions are not published by either government in the same form.
    Still movingTaiwan’s court quorum, Malaysia’s detention review and any new Kelantan legislation were unresolved in October 2026.
    Not adviceA comparison of systems, not an opinion on any case.

    Official sources: law.moj.gov.tw and cons.judicial.gov.tw for Taiwan; sso.agc.gov.sg for Singapore34 / 34