Tratopedia
繁中
Settings

Text size

Language

Theme

High contrast

Version

v1.230.2

The release this page was built from. It is what the service worker caches under.

Slide deck

Back

Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

An active investor is anyone not holding the whole market in its own proportions, and after costs the average one must trail the passive one. Active styles differ by who decides, a person or rules, and by where the reason comes from, a story or numbers.

  1. Explainer

    Active investing: who decides, and where the reason comes from

    Defined by what it is not, then sorted by two questions.

    Active investing1 / 6

  2. Definition

    Active is everything that is not passive

    • 100%of the market, in its own proportions: passive
    • < 100%or other proportions: active

    Active investing2 / 6

  3. Arithmetic

    After costs, the average active dollar trails

    • Before costs: active as a whole earns the market’s return.
    • After costs: it earns less than passive, in any period (Sharpe, 1991).

    Active investing3 / 6

  4. Spectrum 1

    Who decides

    EndStrengthWeakness
    DiscretionaryJudgement in the momentEmotion; hard to back-test
    SystematicDiscipline; testableRules can stop working

    Active investing4 / 6

  5. Spectrum 2

    Where the reason comes from

    EndLooks atExample
    NarrativeA story about the futureA technology theme
    QuantitativeNumbers from the pastValue, momentum, low volatility

    Active investing5 / 6

  6. Close

    Two independent questions

    A quantitative decision “may be systematic or discretionary”: place a strategy on both spectra, not one.

    Active investing6 / 6