Side N
The Front Stopped Moving. The War Did Not.
Which sources back which section of this article, and what its evidence base looks like.
Which sources back which section
| Section | Sources behind it | Count |
|---|---|---|
| What happened | The ISW assessment of 20 September; the UN mission’s August civilian-casualty report; the IAEA Director General’s Update 366; the EIA fuel series; the ACLED Conflict Index. | 5 sources |
| Timeline | The same five, dated from each publisher’s own record, with no additional source introduced. | 5 sources |
| The argument | The ISW assessment of 20 September alone. The section’s whole claim is a pairing within one document, and it deliberately draws on nothing else. | 1 source |
| What others add | The UN mission’s report and publications index; the IAEA update; the EIA series; ACLED; SIPRI; the European Commission’s assistance page; NATO’s Ukraine page; the ICRC’s Ukraine page. | 8 sources |
| Conclusion | The ISW assessment, the UN report, the EIA series and ACLED. It introduces no source the sections above have not already used. | 4 sources |
What the evidence base looks like
- 11Sources used on the page
- 10Read in full at their own address; one at a mirror because its publisher refused
- 7Institutions that count and publish a figure as a matter of routine
- 7Pages approached that refused an unattended request, none of them cited
| Function | How many | How they were read |
|---|---|---|
| Reference | 6 | Full text — bodies that compile and publish a series: the UN mission, the EIA, ACLED, SIPRI and the assessment index |
| Origin | 3 | Full text — institutions writing about their own work: NATO, the European Commission and the ICRC |
| Reporting | 1 | Full text — the daily campaign assessment, which both reports and adjudicates competing claims |
| Reference, at a mirror | 1 | Full text of the agency’s statement, read where it is reproduced because the agency’s own site refused |
Reliable
Reliable, but with an interestWorth believing and reliableWeak on both, and used with careHonest, but thin
Worth believing