Slide deck
BackOnly a product whose fat is essentially all cocoa butter may be called chocolate. The line is 5% added vegetable fat in Taiwan, the EU and Codex, and zero in the United States. Read the ingredients: palm-kernel or coconut oil near the top means a compound.
Research summary · 15 October 2026
Seven products and the cocoa-butter line
Dark, milk, white and ruby chocolate; cocoa butter; and the palm- and coconut-based products that replace it.
Rules · physics · nutrition · price · sustainability · telling them apart1 / 16
In one line
Only a product whose fat is essentially all cocoa butter may be called chocolate
5% is the line
In Taiwan, the EU and the international standard, added vegetable fat above 5% of the product takes the name away.
The US is stricter
American chocolate admits no non-cacao vegetable fat at all.
The ingredients settle it
Palm-kernel oil or coconut oil high in the list means a compound, whatever the front of the packet says.
2 / 16
What is compared
Seven items, in three groups
Group Items What defines it Legal chocolate dark, milk, white, ruby fat from cocoa butter, and milk fat Ingredient cocoa butter melts at 32–35°C; sets the gloss and the snap Compound palm-based, coconut-based vegetable fat replaces cocoa butter; no tempering, lower cost 3 / 16
Definitions
The fat decides whether it may be called chocolate
Item Minimum cocoa Chocolate? Dark total cocoa solids ≥35% yes Milk total cocoa solids ≥25% yes White cocoa butter ≥20% yes Ruby close to milk, with citric acid EU yes; US provisional Cocoa butter — an ingredient, not a chocolate Compounds usually cocoa powder only no, above 5% vegetable fat Minimums: Taiwan, matching Codex and the EU4 / 16
The line
5% of added vegetable fat, in three of the four
- 5%Taiwan
- 5%European Union — listed fats only
- 5%Codex, the international standard
- 0%United States — none permitted
Two other regulators in the region could not be read; see the last slide5 / 16
Side by side
What each one allows, and what it makes you print
Jurisdiction Non-cocoa vegetable fat Labelling Taiwan ≤5% still chocolate; above 5% the name is lost 「添加植物油」 near the name, or 「添加○○油」 European Union ≤5%, and only the six fats on Annex II ‘contains vegetable fats in addition to cocoa butter’, in bold, beside the ingredients United States none, at any percentage a different standardised name — “coating” Codex ≤5%, and it may not reduce the cocoa minimum as each national authority requires Read at each regulator’s own publication, 15 October 20266 / 16
Taiwan
The 代可可脂 labelling was deleted in 2022
- 1 Jan 2017First rule. Over 5% could still be sold as 「代可可脂巧克力」, and filled products were outside it.
- 2 Mar 2021Amendment announced: filled chocolate ≥25% chocolate, spreads and syrups get a floor, and the 代可可脂 labelling goes.
- 1 Jan 2022In force. Above 5% vegetable fat, 「巧克力」 may not be the product name — a product must be renamed, for example 「巧克力風味糖果」.
Much of what circulates is out of date
The regulation file most often passed around is the superseded 2017 text, which still requires 「代可可脂」 — the provision the amendment deleted.
Penalties
Mislabelling: NT$30,000 to 3,000,000. False labelling: NT$40,000 to 4,000,000. A packaged product may also be recalled for correction.
Ministry of Health and Welfare, 巧克力之品名及標示規定7 / 16
Ruby
Launched in 2017 as a fourth kind
Its composition is close to milk chocolate with citric acid added, and the colour comes from lightly fermented beans. The process itself is a trade secret, so what is published about it is third-party reading.
Where Standing European Union sold as a couverture chocolate United States a temporary marketing permit; no standard of identity Taiwan no category of its own: the rule names dark, milk and white The US status was not verified from an agency document here8 / 16
Fat chemistry
Cocoa butter, and the three classes that stand in for it
Class Type Tempering Mixes with cocoa butter Cocoa butter symmetrical POP, POS, SOS required, to Form V — it is the reference CBE non-lauric required any proportion CBR non-lauric not required partial, roughly 20% CBS lauric not required poor — softens and blooms Palm-kernel and coconut are the same class
Both are lauric, so “palm-based” and “coconut-based” products are usually the same sort of thing. Palm fruit oil is the different one — and it is the one on the EU’s permitted list.
9 / 16
Physical behaviour
Why one needs tempering and the other does not
Real chocolate Compound Melting 32–35°C, between room and mouth steep and fast; thinner flavour, waxy or cooling Tempering required, Form V only not required — the main attraction Bloom Form V slipping to VI, or temperature swings eutectics with any cocoa butter present In the heat softens readily holds its shape — why coatings use it Both keep best at 12–20°C, away from light and damp10 / 16
Nutrition
The polyphenols are in the fat-free cocoa solids
- High — dark chocolate
- Middling — ruby and milk chocolate
- Low — compounds, which are flavoured with cocoa powder
- Essentially none — white chocolate and cocoa butter
- 21,442Adults in the largest cocoa-flavanol trial, median 3.6 years
- 0.90Hazard ratio for total cardiovascular events — not significant
- 0.73Hazard ratio for cardiovascular death — a 27% reduction
An extract, not a food
The dose was 500 mg of flavanols a day with no sugar and no fat. This does not support eating more chocolate for your heart.
Sesso and colleagues, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 202211 / 16
Price
Cocoa fell about seventy per cent and the shelf did not follow
Futures ran to a record late in 2024, roughly five times their level two years earlier, then fell back through 2026 as supply recovered and demand was priced away. Reformulation and smaller packs largely did not reverse with it.
What high prices changed
Reformulation, smaller packs, higher prices — and a harder push for equivalents and compounds.
What came back
Not much. A recipe changed under pressure tends to stay changed, so the share of compound products need not fall as the bean does.
Price figures are given as a range: no market-data source could be read for a current quote12 / 16
Sustainability
Three supply chains, three arguments
Chain The figure What it actually is Palm oil 20% Certified sustainable palm oil sold in 2025, 16.2 million tonnes. The “nearly 40%” often quoted is member capacity. Coconut oil a Letter The threatened-species comparison is a Letter with a published erratum, and its ordering reverses per unit area. Both 30 Dec 2026 The EU’s deforestation regulation starts applying to large and medium operators; cocoa and palm oil are both in scope. Swapping one for the other is not an answer
Replacing palm oil with coconut oil cannot be treated as the greener choice on the evidence available.
13 / 16
Telling them apart
Four steps, in the order they pay off
- 1The product nameA flavour, a coating, compound, chocolatey: the plain word was probably unavailable.
- 2The words beside it「添加植物油」 in Taiwan, or ‘contains vegetable fats in addition to cocoa butter’ in the EU, means up to 5% — still chocolate.
- 3The ingredientsPalm-kernel oil, coconut oil or unnamed vegetable fat high in the list means a compound. Cocoa powder with no cocoa butter all but settles it.
- 4The percentageReal chocolate usually states a total cocoa percentage. Compounds usually do not.
Supporting clues: a notably low price; a waxy or cooling mouthfeel; no snap at room temperature14 / 16
Recommendations
Four readers, four different answers
If you are Then Eating it Dark chocolate at 70% or more of total cocoa solids, in sensible portions, and check that no non-cocoa vegetable fat is in the list. Ruby is a pleasure, not a health food. Baking with it A compound is fine for coatings and heat-stable decoration, but it may not be called chocolate on a menu or a wrapper, and it must not be mixed with real chocolate. Exporting it To the United States, no non-cocoa vegetable fat at any percentage. To the EU, only the six Annex II fats, labelled as required, and deforestation data from 30 December 2026. Buying for sustainability Ask for traceability on the cocoa and a segregated or identity-preserved grade on the palm fat. Do not treat a switch to coconut oil as an improvement. 15 / 16
Limits
What could not be checked, and is therefore not claimed
Subject Why it is absent Singapore and Malaysia Both regulators’ texts were refused by their hosts, four attempts in all. Their thresholds, their 5% ceilings and the Malaysian draft category are stated nowhere in this deck. Malaysian cocoa industry Grinding, import and export figures rest on the same unreachable sources, so they are not carried. Ruby’s process A trade secret. What is published about it is third-party reading of patents, not the method. A current cocoa price No market-data source could be read, so the price is given as a range rather than a quote. Nutrition figures Energy, saturated fat and caffeine vary widely by recipe. Only the direction of the comparison is given. Documents read 15 October 202616 / 16