What Happened
Critical Minerals · Governance · Malaysia · Geopolitics · Licence BriefingASX: LYC · Gebeng, Kuantan, Malaysia · licence of March 2026, record to October 2026
Three oxides Lynas sells as heavy rare earths, a ten-year licence with a 2031 deadline for radioactive residue, and an expansion assessment sent back
The only commercial producer of both light and heavy rare earths outside China, so far
Lynas's plant at Gebeng, Pahang, first produced separated dysprosium oxide in May 2025, terbium in June 2025 and samarium in March 2026 — three products Lynas sells as heavy rare earths, although the geochemical grouping places samarium among the light ones. Malaysia renewed the plant's licence for ten years from 3 March 2026, on condition that its radioactive residue stops by 2 March 2031. A proposed increase in the plant's processing was rejected at its first environmental assessment in June 2026, and the estimated cost of a new heavy rare earth facility rose from about A$180m to about A$294m.
- 3Oxides in commercial production that Lynas sells as heavy rare earths
- A$294mEstimated cost of the new heavy rare earth facility, up from about A$180m
- 10 yrsLicence term, 3 March 2026 to 2 March 2036
- 2031Deadline to stop producing radioactive WLP residue
What Is Documented Corroborated by more than one independent report, or stated in the record of the body concerned
| Standing | What | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Confirmed | Separated dysprosium oxide first produced in May 2025, terbium in June 2025 and samarium in March 2026 | Gebeng plant, Pahang; samarium a month ahead of its April target |
| Confirmed | Operating licence renewed for ten years, 3 March 2026 to 2 March 2036, on stricter terms and with a comprehensive review after five years | Under the Atomic Energy Licensing Act 1984; announced by Minister Chang Lih Kang |
| Confirmed | Water Leach Purification (WLP) residue must stop being produced by 2 March 2031, and what is produced until then must be brought below 1 Bq/g | By thorium extraction or another approved method |
| Confirmed | No new permanent disposal facility once the current one is complete; it was 72% complete in October 2025, with four cells filling with WLP residue | Due to be completed by the end of 2026 |
| Confirmed | A new heavy rare earth separation facility, for up to 5,000 t/yr of feedstock, announced on 29 October 2025 at about A$180m; the estimate was raised to about A$294m in July 2026 | Reported at announcement as still subject to regulatory approval |
| Confirmed | The environmental assessment for raising the plant's lanthanide concentrate processing from 95,000 to 110,000 t/yr, plus 69,000 t/yr of mixed rare earth carbonate, was rejected; Lynas said it would submit an updated one | Department of Environment, June 2026; no reason published |
What Is Not Settled Kept apart from the confirmed record above
| Standing | What | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Figures that do not reconcile | The rejected assessment reportedly put the expansion's effect at a 16% increase in WLP residue, or 2.55 million tonnes by March 2031 against 2.41 million without it | The gap of about 140,000 tonnes is about 6% of 2.41 million, so the 16% measures something the reports do not name |
| Scope unclear | Whether that assessment also covers the new heavy rare earth facility, or only the increase in concentrate processing | One report sets the rejection beside the October 2025 plan; the published descriptions of the filing name only the concentrate and carbonate volumes |
| Accurate for now, not permanent | Lynas is the only commercial producer outside China of both light and heavy rare earth oxides | MP Materials in the US was commissioning its own dysprosium and terbium circuit in August 2026, with output expected later that year |
| Not reported | Whether the plant upgrade plan the licence required by 3 June 2026 was submitted | No published statement either way |
Timeline
Key Milestones Compliance deadlines in bold
- 2011Civil society groups begin opposing the plant, before it opens.
- 2012The Lynas Advanced Materials Plant at Gebeng begins operating, on concentrate from Lynas's Mount Weld mine in Western Australia.
- 2020.07.28The Atomic Energy Licensing Board approves land at Bukit Ketam, Pahang, for a permanent disposal facility for WLP residue.
- 2023.10.24A licence variation lets Lynas operate to March 2026, on condition that WLP residue is brought below 1 Bq/g; its research levy rises from 0.5% to 1% of gross sales.
- 2023.11.18A deputy director-general of Nuklear Malaysia says thorium extraction was the agency's idea, not Lynas's — the government had said the proposal came from Lynas.
- 2025.05First separated dysprosium oxide.
- 2025.06First separated terbium oxide.
- 2025.10.09The minister tells Parliament the disposal facility is 72% complete, against a target of 82%, with four cells filling with WLP residue.
- 2025.10.29Lynas announces a new heavy rare earth separation facility at Gebeng, about A$180m (about RM500m).
- 2025.11.15Greenpeace Malaysia and Save Malaysia Stop Lynas urge the government to refuse renewal.
- 2026.01.13Chief Executive Amanda Lacaze announces she will retire after 12 years in the role.
- 2026.03.02The ten-year licence renewal is announced, to run from 3 March 2026 to 2 March 2036.
- 2026.03.03Greenpeace Malaysia says the renewal leaves “unresolved long-standing concerns over radioactive waste management”.
- 2026.03.10Lynas and Japan Australia Rare Earths (JARE) update their supply agreement to 2038, with a US$110/kg floor price for NdPr.
- 2026.03.16Lynas signs a binding letter of intent with the US Department of War: about US$96m of rare earth oxides over four years.
- 2026.03.19Lynas announces its first samarium oxide, produced that month, ahead of its April target.
- 2026.04.08Chief Operating Officer Pol Le Roux says detailed engineering of full heavy rare earth separation is under way, with a full suite on site by late 2027.
- 2026.04.10The environmental assessment for the processing increase goes on public display, to 9 May; comments are taken to 24 May.
- 2026.04.21Lynas reports A$265.0m in quarterly sales revenue and 1,996 tonnes of NdPr.
- 2026.06.03Deadline — the plant upgrade plan is due.
- 2026.06.20The Department of Environment's website shows the assessment rejected, with no reason given.
- 2026.06.23Lynas says it will submit an updated assessment, as the department requested.
- 2026.07.01Pol Le Roux becomes interim chief executive; Amanda Lacaze retired on 30 June.
- 2026.07.22Lynas raises the heavy rare earth facility's estimated cost to about A$294m, citing extra equipment and the cost of sourcing it outside China.
- 2026.08.13MP Materials says it is commissioning its dysprosium and terbium circuit in California, with output expected later in 2026.
- 2026.10.12Minister Johari Abdul Ghani tells Parliament it is technically difficult to know where Lynas's exports end up.
- 2028.03.03From this date — physical construction and modification of the plant.
- 2031.03.02Deadline — production of WLP residue must stop; the licence's five-year review follows.
- 2036.03.02The current licence ends.
The Argument
A Clear End-Point, and the Time It Takes The government's case, and what complicates it
The government's case is that the renewal sets a clear end-point where earlier licences relied on storage. Minister Chang Lih Kang has written that Lynas must stop producing WLP residue by 2 March 2031, that everything produced before then must go through thorium extraction to bring it from about 6 Bq/g to below 1 Bq/g, that no new permanent disposal facility may be built, and that failing the conditions may cost Lynas its licence. He called five years “a firm but accelerated timeline”. His own figures are the complication: laboratory results were promising, he said, but scaling such a process to industrial level typically takes seven to ten years — “up to seven years” in his later written account — against the five the licence allows. Who first proposed the method has itself been disputed. In October 2023 the government said the proposal came from Lynas; in November 2023 a deputy director-general of Nuklear Malaysia, Rawi Zin, said it came from the agency. Greenpeace Malaysia and Save Malaysia Stop Lynas call the extraction economically and technically impractical, because the residue holds on average 1,758 parts per million of thorium.
- <1 Bq/gThe level WLP residue must be brought below, from about 6 Bq/g on the ministry's figure and 6–7 Bq/g on Sahabat Alam Malaysia's.
- 7–10 yrsThe minister's figure for scaling such a process from laboratory to industry; the licence allows five.
- 1%Share of annual gross sales Lynas puts into Malaysian research, raised from 0.5% in October 2023 and kept by the new licence.
Not a routine renewal
The renewal replaces open-ended storage with a dated end-point and caps disposal at the facility already being built; each renewal since a 2018 review has carried stricter conditions than the last. The terms matter beyond one company because the plant is, in AFP's description, the largest commercial producer of separated rare earths outside China. Whether thorium extraction can reach industrial scale in five years, when the minister puts the usual time at seven to ten, is the question the terms leave open.
What Others Add
Three Positions Company · government · environmental groups
Lynas Rare Earths
Locking in demand
- A binding letter of intent with the US Department of War for about US$96m of light and heavy rare earth oxides over four years, with a US$110/kg NdPr floor; the money had been meant for a heavy rare earth plant in Texas.
- An updated agreement with Japan Australia Rare Earths (JARE) to 2038: a firm 5,000 t/yr of NdPr, up to 7,200 t/yr available, and 75% of Lynas's heavy rare earth oxides made available to Japan, with a firm purchase of the equivalent of 50%.
- Amanda Lacaze retired as chief executive on 30 June 2026 after 12 years; Chief Operating Officer Pol Le Roux became interim chief executive on 1 July.
Malaysian Government
Pragmatic, but conditional
- Minister Chang Lih Kang: stricter terms, a comprehensive review after five years, and revocation if Lynas fails the conditions.
- No new permanent disposal facility once the current one is complete, and Lynas is not required to ship existing residue out of Malaysia.
- Trade Minister Johari Abdul Ghani, October 2026: the final destination and use of Lynas's exports are technically difficult to determine.
Environmental Groups
Oversight, not trust
- Greenpeace Malaysia, 3 March 2026: renewing “before fully resolving legacy waste management concerns risks normalising regulatory leniency”; Malaysia's role in the supply chain “must not come at the expense of environmental governance integrity”.
- With Save Malaysia Stop Lynas, in November 2025, it urged the government to refuse renewal and enforce the earlier commitment to move cracking and leaching to Western Australia. Opposition to the plant dates to 2011.
Supply-Chain Context Why the position is strategic, and what the words mean
| Item | Figure | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| China's share of processing | ~90% | China processes and separates about 90% of the world's rare earths, on the US Congressional Research Service's figure, and in 2025 announced export controls on samarium, gadolinium, terbium, dysprosium, lutetium, scandium and yttrium. |
| MP Materials (US), dysprosium and terbium | Commissioning | Circuit mechanically complete in May 2026; on 13 August 2026 the company said output was expected later that year. |
| What counts as heavy | Samarium: light | Geochemical groupings place samarium among the light rare earths, whether the line falls after europium or after gadolinium; Lynas sells it, and MP Materials plans it, among their heavy rare earth products. |
| Pahang's own reserves | ~1.4m t | Valued at about RM37.4bn by the state government in December 2025 — a separate resource, not what Lynas processes: the Gebeng plant runs on concentrate from Mount Weld, Western Australia. |
Conclusion
A Position That Has To Be Renewed, Not Just Held What follows from the record above
Bottom line
Lynas's position — the only commercial producer outside China of separated heavy rare earths — is real, but it is a lead being run, not a fact fixed in place: a US circuit for dysprosium and terbium was being commissioned in August 2026. The growth behind the lead now costs more than announced, and the increase in processing that sits beside it must pass an environmental assessment a second time. Under all of it runs a five-year deadline for a waste treatment the minister himself says normally takes longer to scale. Nothing reported shows any of these will fail; nothing reported yet shows they will succeed on schedule.
What To Watch The nearer-term tests
- The updated environmental assessment for the processing increase — when it is filed, and whether it is approved.
- Published progress on thorium extraction beyond the laboratory — the step the 2031 deadline depends on.
- Whether MP Materials ships dysprosium and terbium from Mountain Pass, which would end Lynas's position as the only producer outside China.
What could not be verified
Unconfirmed report — Save Malaysia Stop Lynas's chairman, Tan Bun Teet, at a joint press conference with Greenpeace Malaysia in November 2025: that Nuklear Malaysia has confirmed no thorium extraction project ever materialised, despite grants. No statement by the agency saying so was found.
Unconfirmed report — a commentary in Malaysiakini, 14 October 2026: that as of 8 October the Department of Environment's portal showed no updated assessment from Lynas. No filing date from the department or from Lynas was found.
Unconfirmed report — AFP, April 2026: that Lynas holds about 10 per cent of the world's rare earth market and China the other 90 per cent. No basis is given; the 90% figure published elsewhere is China's share of processing, not of the market.
Quick notes
- The Star
- Free Malaysia Today
- Associated Press
- MyNewsHub
- Malay Mail
- Malaysiakini
- Mining Weekly
- New Straits Times
- The Vibes
- The Edge
- AFP
- Lynas Rare Earths Limited (ASX announcements and quarterly reports)
- Capital Brief
- The Motley Fool Australia
- MINING.COM
- Greenpeace Malaysia
- MP Materials Corp.
- US Congressional Research Service
- British Geological Survey.
Reliable
Worth believing
Sharing a subject
- Spared the Rise, Not the Bill — Australia's A$2,500 Student Visa and ASEANGovernance · Malaysia
- Partners on Paper: What 1963 Actually PromisedGovernance · Malaysia
- The AISI Cyber Evaluation of Claude Mythos PreviewGovernance
- Tealive and Chatime: 43 Days to Rebrand, 538 to a RulingMalaysia
- Cardano's Van Rossem Fork Meets a Short-Heavy BookGovernance
- Inkling: Thinking Machines' Open Model, and the Rival It Learned FromGeopolitics
- China, North Korea and the Tumen River Sea OutletGeopolitics
- The Spark That Starts a Fire — Anonymous Tip-Offs and Singapore's CPIBGovernance
- A Retreat Executed as a Pivot — BAT Roadmap 4.0 and the Buyback With No NumberGovernance
- Malaysia's Last Coverage Miles, and What a Satellite Can Actually CarryMalaysia
- Agents That Hacked Real Systems to Pass Their Own TestsGovernance
- The Harness Ships, the Governance Doesn’tGovernance
- Same Shock, Two Balance SheetsMalaysia
- Signed in PencilGeopolitics
- Is This Already a World War? Two Answers, and the RecordGeopolitics
- Robinhood Chain Pays Arbitrum — Does ARB Get Paid?Governance
- Who Gets Told When an Agent Breaks SomethingGovernance
- Four Indices, Read on One Day — and One of Them Is Twelve Years BehindMalaysia
- Two Routes to Godhood, and What Each Leaves in the ArchiveMalaysia
- Nobody Can Tell You the OddsGeopolitics
- Three Legal Systems: Malaysia, Singapore and TaiwanMalaysia
- Peter Thiel and the AntichristGovernance
Sharing a source domain
- Partners on Paper: What 1963 Actually Promisedfreemalaysiatoday.com · malaymail.com · malaysiakini.com · theedgemalaysia.com · thestar.com.my · thevibes.com
- Tealive and Chatime: 43 Days to Rebrand, 538 to a Rulingfreemalaysiatoday.com · malaymail.com · nst.com.my · theedgemalaysia.com · thestar.com.my
- Same Shock, Two Balance Sheetsnst.com.my · theedgemalaysia.com · thestar.com.my
- Three Legal Systems: Malaysia, Singapore and Taiwanmalaymail.com · thestar.com.my · thevibes.com
- The Spark That Starts a Fire — Anonymous Tip-Offs and Singapore's CPIBfreemalaysiatoday.com · malaymail.com
- Malaysia's Last Coverage Miles, and What a Satellite Can Actually Carryfreemalaysiatoday.com · theedgemalaysia.com
- Spared the Rise, Not the Bill — Australia's A$2,500 Student Visa and ASEANmalaymail.com
- AWS Adds 2 Million More Nvidia GPUsfool.com
- Four Indices, Read on One Day — and One of Them Is Twelve Years Behindthestar.com.my
- Two Routes to Godhood, and What Each Leaves in the Archivethestar.com.my
- Bruker’s spatial biology division: NanoString, Canopy and Acuityfool.com